Obama Trial Dismissed by Judge Carter
Update October 30, 2009: On September 8, 2009, Judge David O. Carter set a tentative trial date for January 26, 2010. At a hearing on October 5, 2009, Carter considered the defendants' Motion to Dismiss but declined to rule from the bench. October 7, 2009, he released a Minute Order finalizing the previously tentative dates for summary judgment motions and trial, and on October 29, 2009, he dismissed the case. It did seem to be very promising at first. So close, but to no avail.
The expedited trial has been set by Judge Carter for Jan. 26, 2010!
Judge Carter just may be the one to finally take seriously the case of Obama's eligibility to be president. Many concerned veterans and citizens attended the hearing in Federal Court in Santa Ana in the lawsuit against Barack Obama to determine his eligibility to be President and Commander in Chief. About 150 people showed up, almost all in support of the lawsuit to demand that Obama release his birth certificate and other records that he has hidden from the American people.
The hearing lasted from 8:30 to 11:45 AM PT. So give the court credit here. The judge was asking a lot of questions. Over 100 people were in attendence with only standing room remaining. Judge David Carter refused to hear Obama's request for dismissal.
Judge Carter questioned the Defense's counsel, regarding the method of "impeachment" and how that would address this controversy. The defense council stated, "the power to impeach lies totally with the Congress." Orly's reply was priceless: Your honor, "impeachment is for a legitimate President which Obama is NOT.. impeachment should not even be part of our discussion here."
If Obama is in fact an illegitimate president, then he cannot actually be impeached, this would only be an appropriate action if he was in fact a legitimate president and this act could only be carried out by congress. If Obama is not legitimate then it is because he committed fraud, he committed a crime, which means he cannot be impeached and that this case should be addressed by a federal court and not congress.
Concerning the intestinal fortitude of the former marine and speculation as to whether he will stand up for what is right or submit to the elite, interpret this as you may, but he was quoted as stating: "Regarding the Congress, the vast majority of those that run for office are ethical and honest"
The Defense argued that the Court had no authority to hear the case, and that claims were political in nature and therefore not for the Judiciary to adjudicate.
Judge Carter pointed out that the case was unique and that there were no precedents to guide him thoroughly.
Judge Carter questioned on what basis his court could issue a quo warrento proceeding, when the D.C. court had jurisdiction over this kind of proceeding. Dr. Orly Taitz responded by citing precedents in the 9th Circuit, that allowed quo warrento proceedings to be held in California, rather than in Washington, D.C., in account of the great distance to the other side of the continent. Good response by Orly!
Judge David O. Carter issued no ruling on the Motion to Dismiss. He did not grant discovery. He cited his need to sort out the complex legal issues, consider all the arguments carefully.
He indicated there was almost no chance that this case would be dismissed. Obama is arguing this lawsuit was filed in the wrong court if you can believe that. Judge Carter denied Attorney Gary Kreep's Motion for Severance, which would have created a parallel case, for his clients. Assuming Judge Carter denies Obama's motion for dismissal, he will likely then order expedited discovery which will force Obama to release his birth certificate in a timely manner (if he has one).
The judge, WHO IS A FORMER U.S. MARINE, repeated several times that this is A VERY SERIOUS CASE which must be resolved quickly so that the troops know that their Commander in Chief is eligible to hold that position and issue lawful orders to our military in this time of war. He basically said OBAMA MUST PROVE HIS ELIGIBILITY to the court! He said Americans deserve to know the truth about their President!
The two U.S. Attorneys representing Barack Obama tried everything they could to sway the judge that this case was frivolous, but Carter would have none of it and cut them off several times. Obama's attorneys left the courtroom after about the 90 minute hearing looking defeated and nervous.
